NIS-3 Child Abuse Table 5-2, Page 5-11

xmas3.gif (5334 bytes)

The Truth About Child Murder

The Relationship between Sex, Household Incomes, Families, and Child Abuse

The Third National Incidence Study of Child Abuse and Neglect (NIS-3)

US Department of Health and Human Services, page 6-11, table 6-4

To get a copy of this vital report, call 800 FYI 3366 and ask for NIS-3

Executive Summary

Front cover

Selected tables:

Fewer than 20 children were murdered by their fathers in 1996.
Children are 40% more likely to be abused in single-mother households than in single-father households.
Children are 50 times more likely to be physically abused in low income than high income households.
The Bureau of Justice Statistics provides statistical proof of anti-male bias in the justice system.

Overview:

NIS-3 is a comprehensive, credible nationwide study of the extent of child abuse and who the perpetrators are.

It reports that in 1993 children were 59 times more likely to be fatally abused [read: murdered] by natural mothers than by natural fathers.

It reports that women constitute 78% of the perpetrators of fatal child abuse.

The asterisk in Table 6-4 shows that the number of child murders committed by biological fathers was "fewer than 20 cases with which to calculate estimate" [read: less than 2% of children who are murdered are murdered by their natural fathers].

Excluded from this estimate are 3,100 children who are murdered each year by their mothers which are mis-reported as SIDS!

It illustrates that, compared to children in families, children in single-mother households are:

	4 times more likely to be financially disadvantaged.
	20 times more likely to be fatally abused.
	22 times more likely to be seriously abused.
	20 times more likely to be moderately abused.
	27 times more likely to be emotionally neglected.
	50 times more likely to be physically neglected.
	55 times more likely to be educationally neglected.

It took 8 years for the mainstream media to finally get around to reporting the truth about mothers' role in fatal child abuse, which is a travesty to the children who might otherwise have been spared murder and serious abuse by mothers. No government internet source has yet presented the full story, which is available in hard copy at 800 394-3366. Casanet http://www.casanet.org/library/abuse/nis-study-93.htm barely gave the statistics in this study honorable mention and the DHHS web site is devoid of all the important related facts.

What they didn't want you to know is that 1,009,970 children are "maltreated" every year, 906,075 of them by natural mothers, which means that natural mothers abuse 63% more children than natural fathers and 8.4 times as many children as are abused by other men. The statistics for serious abuse are even worse: natural mothers seriously abuse 88% more children than natural fathers and 17 times more children than other men. There is no category in which natural fathers abuse more children than natural mothers. Even in moderate and inferred abuse, natural mothers abuse 50% and 44%, respectively, more children than natural fathers.

Natural mothers seriously abuse and moderately abuse 16 times more children than other men, they seriously abuse 38 times more children than other women, and overall they maltreat 48 times more children than other women.

If you carefully consider the consequences of the following comparison to other statistical sources, you will realize the role the federal government played with the media in demonizing the safest place in the world for America's children: with their biological fathers:

The higher accident rate of women kills 620 times as many men in traffic accidents as fathers kill children.
Mothers murder six times as many children as husbands murder wives.
Women murder 140 times as many men as fathers murder children.
Including mis-reported SIDS cases, mothers are 215 times as likely as biological fathers to kill their children [(1,200 children known to have been murdered by mothers + 3,100 mis-reported SIDS cases) / 20 children known to have been murdered by their fathers]

Table 6—4, Page 6-11 of this report, entitled "Distribution of Perpetrator's Sex by Severity of Outcome and Perpetrator's Relationship to Child" shows the following data (See the original chart here):

	Percent Children in Maltreatment Category	Total Maltreated Children	Percent of Children in Row with Perpetrator Whose Sex was Male	Percent of Children in Row with Perpetrator Whose Sex was Female	Percent of Children in Row with Perpetrator Whose Sex was Unknown
FATAL	100%	1,500	*	78%	*
Natural parents	80%	1,200	*	*	*
Other Parents and Parent/substitutes	*	*	*	*	*
Others	*	*	*	*	*
SERIOUS	100%	565,000	48%	75%	*
Natural parents	87%	490,000	43%	81%	*
Other Parents and Parent/substitutes	8%	43,000	77%	49%	*
Others	6%	32,000	77%	*	*
MODERATE	100%	822,000	55%	66%	*
Natural parents	80%	653,700	48%	72%	*
Other Parents and Parent/substitutes	16%	128,000	87%	47%	*
Others	5%	40,300	69%	31%	*
INFERRED	100%	165,300	72%	30%	*
Natural parents	38%	63,300	45%	65%	*
Other Parents and Parent/substitutes	24%	40,000	86%	*	*
Others	38%	62,100	90%	*	*
ALL MALTREATMENT	100%	1,553,800	54%	65%	1%
Natural parents	78%	1,208,100	46%	75%	*
Other Parents and Parent/substitutes	14%	211,200	85%	41%	*
Others	9%	134,500	80%	14%	7%

	* Fewer than 20 cases with which to calculate estimate; estimate too unreliable to be given.

One other aspect of this table deserves comment: the overall pattern of sex differences across the perpetrator categories appears to hold at each severity level. Overall, more of the children maltreated by their birth parents were maltreated by their mothers, whereas those maltreated by other parents and parent-substitutes or by other perpetrators were more often maltreated by males. From what can be determined, this appears to be true for children who suffered inferred injuries or impairments, those who suffered moderate injuries or impairments, and those who suffered serious injuries or impairments. The data were insufficient to allow this question to be addressed for children who suffered fatal injuries or impairments.

The Census Bureau reports that the median household income of a two working parent family is $51,950, of a one working parent family is $36,786, and of a single-mother household is $18,000:

	http://www.census.gov:80/hhes/income/mednhhld/ta3.html and
	http://www.census.gov:80/hhes/income/mednhhld/ta8.html

NIS-3 shows that more than 19 out of 20 of most forms of child abuse occur in households with annual incomes less than $15,000. This means that very few children in families, maybe less than 1%, are subjected to any form of abuse. The following asymptotic curves never touch the x-axis, theoretically, but in reality the number of children physically, emotionally, sexually, or educationally abused or neglected in families is extremely small.

The inference is that two incomes or higher incomes is responsible for reducingchild abuse. The reality is that it is the presence of the father in both one working parent families and two working parent families which is responsible for both the higher incomes and the reduced child abuse.

Outlawing single-mother households would not only cut child abuse by more than 95%, but it would eliminate the need for CAPTA, implemented by the Mondale Bill, which currently costs taxpayers more than $285 billion per year.

nis3abuseincome6.gif (36363 bytes)

divorcekills500k.gif (16162 bytes)

Download the original studies and data from divorcekills500000.xls

which shows how divorce and illegitimacy kills an extra half a million Americans each year.

Table 5-2, Page 5-11, NIS-3, The Third National Incidence Study of Child Abuse and Neglect, Incidence Rates per 1,000 Children for Maltreatment under the Endangerment Standard in the NIS-3 (1993) for Different Levels of Family Income (800 FYI 3366 for a FREE copy)
	<$15,000/year	$15-29,000/year	$30,000/year	Ratio $15K:$30K
All Maltreatment	95.9	33.1	3.8	25.2
Abuse	37.4	17.5	2.5	15
Physical	17.6	8.5	1.5	11.7
Sexual	9.2	4.2	0.5	18.4
Emotional	18.3	8.1	1.0	18.3
Neglect	72.3	21.6	1.6
Physical	54.3	12.5	1.1	49.4
Emotional	19	8.2	0.7	27
Educational	11.1	4.8	0.2	55.5
Severity of Injury
Fatal	0.060	0.002	0.003	20
Serious	17.9	7.9	0.8	22.4
Moderate	29.6	12.1	1.5	19.7
Inferred	7.8	2.7	0.2	39
Endangered	40.5	10.3	1.3	31.3

Correcting the error in NIS-3.

Hit Counter

Modified Saturday, March 11, 2017